We have to stop taking art for granted. Many of the people who fill our lives with joy and creativity are also struggling to get by, and that’s in large part because of how corporations have stacked the deck to enrich themselves at the expense of the people creating that art.
Open in browser
Wednesday July 27, 2022
REDEF
Turnstile jumper: Singer Brendan Yates of Baltimore hardcore band Turnstile at the Slottsfjell fest, Tønsberg, Norway, July 14, 2022.
(Per Ole Hagen/Redferns/Getty Images)
quote of the day
We have to stop taking art for granted. Many of the people who fill our lives with joy and creativity are also struggling to get by, and that’s in large part because of how corporations have stacked the deck to enrich themselves at the expense of the people creating that art.
- Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich., author of a Congressional resolution asking the federal government to establish a new statutory streaming royalty for musicians
rantnrave://
English Beat

UK newsflash: As the music streaming market becomes more and more saturated, a million streams per month will now earn an artist around £12,000 a year. It’s hard out here for a middle class artist. But it’s easier than ever for the consumers doing all that streaming, according to the UK’s competition watchdog, the COMPETITION & MARKETS AUTHORITY, which released a preliminary report Tuesday after six months of study into the economics of the country’s streaming music market. In a win for major labels and streaming services and a blow to artist and songwriter advocates and indie labels, the authority rejected calls for a full-blown investigation into the market. Although the market is dominated by three major labels and financial success is concentrated among a small group of artists “while the majority made no substantial earnings,” the authority suggested the industry is broadly healthy, no tougher for artists than it ever has been, and consumers—the main focus of the authority’s work—are being well served. Government interventions “are unlikely to drive significant improvements to artist and consumer outcomes” the report said, and, at best, “may help some types of artists, but in doing so, may risk the unintended consequence of redistributing revenues from one group of artists to another.”

The BBC’s SHIONA MCCALLUM does a good job summing up the report’s findings and implications while noting the many objections to its conclusions from artists, songwriters and other stakeholders, and STUART DREDGE at Music Ally has highlighted a bunch of stats and other points of interest within. The Twitter feed of musician/activist TOM GRAY, founder of the #BrokenRecord campaign, one of the groups that pushed the authority to go further, is also worth a read.

A final report isn’t due until next January and Gray promised to keep pushing between now and then. But any hopes for a different outcome may have been doomed from the start by the nature of the authority’s work, which was to assure “competition is working well for consumers by delivering high-quality, innovative services for low prices.”

"Rhapsody, the first streaming service, cost $9.99 in 2001," Gray told the BBC. “Streaming costs the same 21 years later. Obviously, that is a good deal for consumers—but is it destructive to the value of music itself? The answer ought to be, 'Yes.'"

The report doesn’t suggest the answer is anything else. It suggests that wasn’t the question.

American Pie

Meanwhile in the US: Congresswoman RASHIBA TLAIB, a Michigan Democrat, is proposing a resolution that would call on the federal government to create a statutory streaming royalty for musicians. It’s the government’s job, she says, to make sure musicians receive “reasonable remuneration through a royalty payment earned on a per-stream basis.”

Summer Awards Season

Atoning, perhaps, for sister network BET’s snub of LIL NAS X at this year’s BET AWARDS, MTV has showered him with seven nominations for the VMAs. Lil Nas X is tied with his “INDUSTRY BABY” collaborator JACK HARLOW and KENDRICK LAMAR atop the nominations list for the Aug. 28 awards show. DOJA CAT and HARRY STYLES are also up for their share of Moon People... Styles can also be found on the shortlist for the prestigious MERCURY PRIZE, for the best album by a British or Irish artist. Other finalists for the prize, to be awarded Sept. 8, include WET LEG, LITTLE SIMZ, KOJEY RADICAL and YARD ACT... BILLY STRINGS, MOLLY TUTTLE, SISTER SADIE, the PO RAMBLIN’ BOYS and DEL MCCOURY will compete for Entertainer of the Year at the IBMA BLUEGRASS MUSIC AWARDS on Sept. 29. Strings won the honor in 2021.

Etc Etc Etc

The euphoria of stumbling upon weird cover songs on SPOTIFY... Love letters to bands rescued by a janitor at the PAGEANT in St. Louis... What’s with all the ‘90s alt-rock t-shirts in JORDAN PEELE’s NOPE?

- Matty Karas (@troubledoll), curator
i'll dance to that
BBC News
Music industry as tough as it has always been, watchdog says
By Shiona McCallum
The UK's competition watchdog has found streaming has made the music industry challenging for many artists. But it rejected calls for a full market investigation because "our initial findings have not identified any significant concerns in terms of consumer outcomes relating to music streaming".
Competition & Markets Authority
Music and Streaming: Market Study Update [PDF]
Our study assesses the impact streaming has had on the music sector and whether competition is working well for consumers by delivering high-quality, innovative services for low prices. We have also considered the position of songwriters and artists, to consider concerns raised by some stakeholders that the market is not serving creators’ interests sufficiently.
The New York Times
The Case of the $5,000 Springsteen Tickets
By Ron Lieber
Triumphant fans showed up in Ticketmaster’s queue with special codes, only to encounter its “dynamic pricing” system. Was the Boss OK with that?
Rolling Stone
After Roe’s Fall, They Turned Their Songs Into Abortion Fund Donations
By Cheyenne Roundtree
Artists like Halsey, Paramore, Gracie Abrams, quinnie and Margo Price are continuing to fundraise and advocate for abortion rights.
VICE
How the Music Industry Silences Women and Nonbinary People
By Nana Baah, Hannah Ewens, Nilu Haidari...
Eight industry insiders in the UK reveal the toxic behaviour and patterns that run rife in music.
Los Angeles Times
'I was ugly-crying most of the time': Wynonna Judd on being part of Joni Mitchell's comeback concert
By Mikael Wood
Musicians Wynonna Judd and Blake Mills, and a Newport Folk Festival producer, recount the lead up to, and miracle of, Mitchell's surprise performance.
The New Yorker
The Age of Algorithmic Anxiety
By Kyle Chayka
Interacting online today means being besieged by system-generated recommendations. Do we want what the machines tell us we want?
The Ringer
Meet the Man Trying to Move Emo Beyond Its 'Hair Metal' Past
By Justin Sayles
Think emo only refers to the four years you were in high school? Think again. We sat down with the person behind IsThisBandEmo.com and the ‘Washed Up Emo’ podcast to talk about the genre’s long history and bright future.
Orbiting Punk
Punks from the Sunshine State
By Dalton Spangler
Why Florida is a punk-producing, emo-ecosystem.
God's Music Is My Life
Sylvester and the Gospel Impulse
By Tim Dillinger
Remembering 3 of the soul and disco icon's gospel-inspired moments.
he'll understand
Loudwire
A Brief History of More Than 30 Formats Music Has Officially Been Released On
By Chris Wheatley
From the initial wax cylinder to USB sticks in gummy skulls.
Music Business Worldwide
Managers of Bad Bunny, The Killers join $3 million fundraising for ‘the LegalZoom for the music business’
New York-based Creative Intell, which describes itself as an artificial intelligence-powered dealmaking platform for the music industry, has raised USD $3 million in its seed funding round.
gal-dem
Where the music and media industries have failed, whisper networks have provided solace and community
By ​Jumi Akinfenwa
Jumi Akinfenwa explores how whisper networks have long operated under the radar – and the consequences once they’ve been thrown into the spotlight.
Egyptian Streets
Shik Shak Shok: The Song That Empowers Young Egyptian Women
By Salma Hamed
A wedding, a henna (bachelorette party), a birthday party, a bedroom, or even during lunch breaks in abandoned middle-school classrooms: these are all places where the infamous sound of Shik Shak Shok rings as girls and women of all ages dance freely, unabashedly.
The New York Times
Teodor Currentzis and MusicAeterna Face Scrutiny Over Russian Ties
By Javier C. Hernández
Teodor Currentzis and the ensemble MusicAeterna have faced backlash in the West over their partnership with a state-owned bank in Russia.
Gawker
The Euphoria of Stumbling Upon Weird Spotify Cover Songs
By Luke Winkie
It’s like scrolling through the trenches of Limewire all over again.
theLAnd
Welcome to the Jungles
By Harley Geffner
In just one year, the Baby Stone Gorillas have gone from Section 8 housing to L.A.’s biggest new rap group.
Catapult
Shakira’s Crossover into American Music Taught Me to Reject My Latinx Roots--Then Reclaim Them
By Tasha Sandoval
The arc of my journey with Shakira traces a path from veneration to rejection to reembrace.
what we're into
Music of the day
“Take It Like a Man (live)”
Amanda Shires
Title song from album out Friday on ATO.
Music | Media
SUBSCRIBE
Suggest a link
“REDEF is dedicated to my mother, who nurtured and encouraged my interest in everything and slightly regrets the day she taught me to always ask ‘why?’”
Jason Hirschhorn
CEO & Chief Curator
HOME | ABOUT | SETS | PRESS
Redef Group Inc.
LA - NY - Everywhere
Copyright ©2021
UNSUBSCRIBE or MANAGE MY SUBSCRIPTION