The best feeling in the world is the euphoria around the first idea of writing a great song. That feeling has now turned into 'Oh wait, let's stand back for a minute.' You find yourself in the moment, second-guessing yourself.
Open in browser
Monday April 11, 2022
REDEF
Might as well jump: Billie Eilish at the Forum, Inglewood, Calif., April 8, 2022.
(Kevin Mazur/Getty Images)
quote of the day
The best feeling in the world is the euphoria around the first idea of writing a great song. That feeling has now turned into 'Oh wait, let's stand back for a minute.' You find yourself in the moment, second-guessing yourself.
- Ed Sheeran, on pop-music plagiarism lawsuits
rantnrave://
Fake Book

If you're one of those people, and there are a lot of you, who think the pandemic of fake artists on SPOTIFY and other subscription services is no big deal, if you think they're just another group of artists making money from the system instead of more famous names and therefore good for them, I beg you to read this essay from TED GIOIA, riffing on an anonymous music bizzer's account in MUSIC BIZ WORLDWIDE, which I also beg you to read. Because there are two big problems when this particular brand of fake artist invades our algorithms: It doesn't appear to be artists making that money—record companies and tech companies are collecting those dollars *instead* of artists—and it's a terrible experience for millions of music fans who subscription services are feeding mediocre music to. It’s the system abdicating its responsibility to help music fans discover good music.

The experience Gioia outlines was easy for me to duplicate. Go to Spotify, type the word "jazz" in the search box and behold the results. My top result is the same as his: an official Spotify playlist called "Jazz in the Background," whose title is disturbingly on-the-nose. It's music that the service is telling me isn't meant to be listened to, much of it by artists who are obscure by design. If you were a record store clerk named DANIEL EK and a customer told you nothing more than that they were interested in jazz, is this the music you'd point them to? The top three artists who show up under my jazz search include JAZZ FRUITS MUSIC, which doesn't appear to be an actual artist but a collection of low-budget library music released by a label, STRANGE FRUITS, which Music Biz Worldwide's source says specializes in pseudonymous artists making low or no royalties. One of the top three albums is a two-song, five-minute release by HARA NODA, an artist best known among jazz aficionados for appearing on that Jazz in the Background playlist. And so on. The official playlist feeds the algorithm which in turn amplifies the playlist and the fake artists on it.

If the whistleblowing is correct, much of this music is made by artists whose output is work-for-hire, meaning they're not getting the royalties that normally come with streaming plays. Those royalties may be fractions of fractions of pennies per play, but in the aggregate—Jazz in the Background has 210 songs and 650,000 followers—that can be a lot of money diverted away from the standard artist royalty pie. Depending on the particulars of any given fake/anonymous artist, the beneficiaries are the labels who control the music or the subscription service itself. All three majors, apparently, and lots of indies do this. And a lot of the anonymous creators, strangely, appear to be from Spotify's home country, Sweden.

Even if the whistleblowing is wrong, jazz fans and/or music fans who are curious about jazz are getting decidedly questionable recommendations from a service they're paying to be their music guide. I listen to a lot of jazz, both new and old, on Spotify. I have no doubt Ted Gioia listens to far more. Why is Spotify, which prides itself on personalization, on knowing its users' listening preferences, pointing us to this stuff when there's so much great jazz, both new and old, out there? We're living in a jazz golden age. It's hard enough for the musicians responsible for it to find a fanbase and make a living without a giant music tech company standing purposefully in the way.

You Listenin' to Me?

A legit promoter is doing this at a legit venue in Brooklyn this summer because why?

Rest in Peace

CHRIS BAILEY, lead singer of pioneering Australian punk-rockers the Saints. "Rock music in the seventies was changed by three bands," Bob Geldof once said. "The Sex Pistols, the Ramones and the Saints." "We all felt brushed by the Saints’ wings," said Robert Forster of fellow Brisbane natives the Go-Betweens... British jazz singer TINA MAY.

- Matty Karas (@troubledoll), curator
stranded on my own
Culture Notes of an Honest Broker
The Fake Artists Problem Is Much Worse Than You Realize
By Ted Gioia
Recent revelations from an alleged industry insider paint a disturbing picture.
Music Business Worldwide
An MBW reader just blew open the Spotify fake artists story. Here’s what they have to say
By Murray Stassen
This is an email you're gonna want to read.
NPR Music
Meme Girls: Three squares talk about Wet Leg, the band everybody's talking about
By Ann Powers, Jacob Ganz and Hazel Cills
Wet Leg, the year's breakout indie rock band, just released a debut album full of loopy, addictive songs that are as fun to talk about as they are to listen to.
Passion of the Weiss
How Prodigy Changed Hip-Hop Forever By Stabbing a Couch
By Jaap van der Doelen
The late rapper created the grassroots online promo campaign that has become a staple for independent hip-hop, all centered on his magnificent comeback record with Alchemist.
The Atlantic
Pop Music’s Nostalgia Obsession
By Shirley Li, Spencer Kornhaber, Hannah Giorgis...
Why do older sounds seem to dominate music lately?
Trapital
Audiomack CMO Dave Ponte’s Plan to Grow the Pie for Artists
By Dan Runcie and Dave Ponte
Audiomack says is wants to increase the “size of the pie” for the entire music industry — not merely find additional ways to ”slice the pie.” Co-founder Dave Ponte and I spoke at length about artist monetization — and how Web 3.0 possibly fits into the equation.
The Sydney Morning Herald
How Chris Bailey and the Saints shocked Australia, rock’n’roll, and me
By Michael Dwyer
The frontman and co-founder of The Saints died on the weekend, aged 65.
Billboard
BTS Closes Out ‘Permission to Dance’ Las Vegas Weekend One With Career-Defining Highlight Reel of Moments
By Melinda Sheckells
Sin City became “The City” as the K-pop group’s devoted ARMY invaded the Strip.
The Guardian
How Beethoven inspired 50 years of cultural exchange between the US and China
By Vincent Ni
A new book tells how classical music, played to the Chinese by the Philadelphia Orchestra, ushered in decades of valuable interchanges now under threat.
CBS Sunday Morning
The Randy Rainbow Story: How his satirical songs went viral
By Rita Braver
His music videos lampooning politicians and culture warriors have made the comedian (truth: his real name) a social media sensation.
stranded far from home
The New Yorker
The Misunderstood Voice of Nico
By Brian Dillon
Who was the artist behind the icon?
The Guardian
Prison, lawsuits and a glovebox of fake cash: the film the KLF didn’t want you to see
By Chris Atkins
The enigmatic rave duo refused to approve Chris Atkins’s documentary on them -- and then he got five years for tax fraud. He explains how he channelled their anarchic spirit and made it anyway, Ford Timelord and all.
Los Angeles Times
Gustavo Dudamel in Venezuela makes for a riveting new documentary, '¡Viva Maestro!'
By Mark Swed
The new documentary by Theodore Braun gets at the heart of L.A. Phil conductor Gustavo Dudamel - and captures him pushed to his limits.
Billboard
Why the CRB Threw Out the Major Labels and NMPA’s Rate Settlement
By Ed Christman
Sony’s Jon Platt applauds the songwriters and their advocates who made the case for higher mechanical rates.
Hypebeast
The Last Thing Syd Wants To Be Is Bitter
By Sophie Caraan
Although her first solo album in five years was delayed by heartbreak, she now finds herself content and focused on the things that truly matter to her.
The FADER
billy woods and Preservation on the cinematic chaos of 'Aethiopes'
By Raphael Helfand, billy woods and Preservation
The rapper and producer discuss their new collaborative album on the latest episode of The FADER Interview.
Rest of World
One year after Spotify entered Pakistan, musicians are cautiously optimistic
By Hina Husain
Pakistani artists have struggled to monetize their work. Some think the streaming platform has the power to fix what’s wrong with the industry.
BBC Radio 4
Desert Island Discs: Robert Plant, singer and songwriter
By Lauren Laverne and Robert Plant
Robert Plant, singer, shares the soundtrack of his life with Lauren Laverne.
The Sydney Morning Herald
The Big Day Out was adored by fans but no one loved it more than Ken West
By Martin Boulton
Ken West was passionate about art, creativity and putting on the biggest show in town.
female:pressure
An Open Letter about MOMEM
By Electric Indigo
With great irritation we have taken note of the events for the opening of MOMEM – Museum of Modern Electronic Music in Frankfurt. The opening of MOMEM is exclusively in the hands of cis men (Sven Väth, Sami Hugo, Sven Louis and Noe Fazi as DJs, Tobias Rehberger as curator), MOMEM’s team of directors is also 100% male. 
what we're into
Music of the day
“Who Do Men Say I Am?”
Pastor Champion
Possibly my favorite song from possibly my favorite album (so far) of 2022, "I Just Want to Be a Good Man," out now on Luaka Bop. Pastor Champion, a traveling preacher, gospel singer and carpenter, died just months before this, his very belated first album, was released.
Video of the day
“Storm of Life (Stand By Me) [live in Oakland, circa 2011]”
Pastor Champion
"I make my songs up. I mean, I really make 'em up." There are a handful of Pastor Champion performances on YouTube and they're uniformly great.
Music | Media
SUBSCRIBE
Suggest a link
“REDEF is dedicated to my mother, who nurtured and encouraged my interest in everything and slightly regrets the day she taught me to always ask ‘why?’”
Jason Hirschhorn
CEO & Chief Curator
HOME | ABOUT | SETS | PRESS
Redef Group Inc.
LA - NY - Everywhere
Copyright ©2021
UNSUBSCRIBE or MANAGE MY SUBSCRIPTION